package_hero
01 What we foundOur own screening — every ingredient graded, then set beside the category best sellers.
The dhaliora verdict

How this pick earned its score

Every ingredient is graded on an EWG-style scale, then weighted with our own use-experience and curation read into one Dhaliora score.
The category's best sellers below are scored with the same formula.

SHINGMULNARA Young Green Tea Tube Cleansing Balm 100ml
Our pick

A fragrance-free, PEG-free green-tea cleansing balm in a hygienic squeeze tube, a soft balm-to-oil with a big botanical cast, cleaner than fragranced jar balms.

9.8
/ 10
Dhaliora score
How we grade →
Amazon best sellers
Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing Balm
Farmacy Green Clean Cleansing BalmPapaya 'super greens' balm-to-oil

Why ours wins — A cult super-greens balm with papaya enzymes, but a PEG-based, papaya-themed cleanser where ours is PEG-free and green-tea-led.

9.2
/ 10
Cetyl EthylhexanoateEmollientCaprylic/Capric TriglycerideEmollientPolyethyleneStructuring AgentCarica Papaya Fruit ExtractEnzyme
Banila Co Clean It Zero Original Balm
Banila Co Clean It Zero Original BalmCategory-defining sherbet balm

Why ours wins — The benchmark jar balm, effective at melting makeup, but fragranced and PEG-based where our green-tea balm is fragrance- and PEG-free.

8.6
/ 10
Ethylhexyl PalmitateEmollientCetyl EthylhexanoateEmollientSynthetic WaxStructuring Agent
Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm
Elemis Pro-Collagen Cleansing BalmAnti-ageing shea-and-olive cleansing balm

Why ours wins — A luxe shea-and-olive balm that melts makeup, but a fragranced, essential-oil-rich formula where our green-tea squeeze balm stays fragrance- and PEG-free.

9.0
/ 10
Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) ButterEmollientOlea Europaea (Olive) Fruit OilEmollientLavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) OilEssential OilTocopherolAntioxidantCaprylic/Capric TriglycerideEmollient
OliveYoung best sellers
Dr.G Green Deep Pore Cleansing Balm
Dr.G Green Deep Pore Cleansing BalmGreen-line pore-care cleansing balm

Why ours wins — The closest green-themed rival with green-tea seed oil and neem for pores, but fragranced and PEG-based where we stay fragrance- and PEG-free.

9.1
/ 10
Cetyl EthylhexanoateEmollientEthylhexyl PalmitateEmollient
Manyo Deep Cleansing Balm
Manyo Deep Cleansing BalmPlant-oil sherbet cleansing balm

Why ours wins — A best-selling plant-oil balm that melts makeup well, but an oil-blend theme rather than our green-tea botanical cleanse.

9.2
/ 10
Ethylhexyl PalmitateEmollientSorbeth-30 TetraoleateEmulsifierIsododecaneMakeup SolventOlea Europaea (Olive) Fruit OilEmollientSqualaneEmollientglycine soja (soybean) oilemollient
Heimish All Clean Balm
Heimish All Clean BalmBest-selling sherbet oil cleansing balm

Why ours wins — Korea's cult sherbet balm, effective but built on PEG emulsifiers and fragrant flower oils, where our green-tea balm stays PEG- and fragrance-free.

9.0
/ 10
Ethylhexyl PalmitateEmollientCetyl EthylhexanoateEmollientPolyethyleneStructuring AgentButyrospermum Parkii (Shea) ButterEmollientTocopheryl AcetateAntioxidant1,2-HexanediolPreservative

Scores are Dhaliora's composite reading — ingredient safety screened against publicly available data (EWG-style 1–10), weighted with our own use-experience and curation judgment. Not a third party's score, and not medical advice.

Why it works

What this formula actually does

Built around camellia sinensis (green tea) extract and screened ingredient by ingredient — here is what earns its place.

01

Green-tea balm-to-oil

Green-tea water and extract in a soft sherbet balm melt base and light makeup, sebum and grime, then rinse away.

02

Hygienic squeeze tube

A squeeze format means no spatula and no water in a jar, keeping the balm cleaner than a pot.

03

Clean, botanical-rich formula

PEG-free and fragrance-free with a large plant-extract complex; all 33 ingredients screen low-risk.

Ingredient transparency

Read it like a label, not a promise

We publish the full ingredient list and risk ratings so you can check it against your own sensitivities.
Grades are our own EWG-style reading — not a third party's proprietary score, and not medical advice.

SHINGMULNARA · fully listed

33 ingredients, screened

9.8/ 10 · Dhaliora score
33fully listed
33low-risk
0mid-risk
0high-risk
Risk distribution · 33 graded
33
Low — well-tolerated · 33 Mid — use-rated · 0 High — patch-test · 0
Free ofFragrance-freePEG-freeParaben-freeColorant-free
Hero ingredient — Camellia Sinensis (Green Tea) Extract.
How grades are set — Dhaliora screens each ingredient against publicly available safety data (EWG-style 1–10). Grades reflect our own reading, not any third party's proprietary score, and are not medical advice.

Our take

Most cleansing balms come in a jar and lean on fragrance and PEG emulsifiers. This one squeezes cleanly from a tube, melts makeup on a green-tea and botanical base, and stays fragrance- and PEG-free. Best for anyone who wants a gentle, hygienic daily balm for light-to-medium makeup; double-cleanse for heavy or waterproof makeup, and keep it away from the eyes. On a clean formula and hygienic format it stands out from fragranced jar balms, which is why it earns its place.

Worth knowing

  • Light, not for heavy makeupIt handles base and light-to-medium makeup, so waterproof or full point makeup needs a double cleanse or dedicated remover.
  • Temperature-sensitive, can sting eyesThe texture softens in summer and firms in winter, and it can sting if it gets into the eyes.
02 What buyers reportDrawn from customer reviews of this product, not from us.
AI review insights

An affordable green-tea cleansing balm in a hygienic tube.

Tube balmMelts makeupHygienicAffordableGreen tea

Across 21 Hwahae reviews the strongest signals are an affordable, well-cleansing balm in a hygienic no-drip tube that melts makeup away.

21Hwahae Reviews
4.43Hwahae Avg. Rating
#15Cleansing Balm Ranking

Strengths

Affordable7
Cleanses well7
Moisturizing5
Hygienic tube4
Doesn't drip3
Not slippery2
Green-tea scent1

Frictions — read as fit guidance

Tube format not for all3
Less ideal in summer heat2
Can sting eyes2
Doesn't clear blackheads2
Limited deep-impurity removal2
E
Elsa
Everyday makeup · Dislikes messy jars · Value

“The tube is so tidy and hygienic compared to a tub, and it melts my everyday makeup off easily without feeling harsh, all at a great price.”

An AI-generated representative voice, based on aggregated Korean customer review signals. Not a real customer.
P
Preeti
Combination skin · First cleanse · Travel

“It is a nice affordable first cleanse that doesn't drip, and it is easy to travel with; I follow with a foam wash for a deeper clean.”

An AI-generated representative voice, based on aggregated Korean customer review signals. Not a real customer.
M
Meiling
Dry skin · Hygiene-conscious · Repurchase

“I like not having to dip fingers into a tub, and it leaves my skin clean but not stripped, so I keep repurchasing it as my daily balm.”

An AI-generated representative voice, based on aggregated Korean customer review signals. Not a real customer.

Good fit if

  • Anyone who wants an affordable, hygienic tube cleansing balm
  • People removing everyday makeup who like a no-drip format
  • Value shoppers wanting a simple first-cleanse balm

Set expectations

  • Deep pore or blackhead removal — pair with a second cleanse
  • A cooling summer-friendly feel — reviewers prefer it in cooler weather
  • A sting-free experience near the eyes — keep it away from the eyes

All insights in this section are AI-generated analyses of individual customer reviews. They describe common patterns — not medical advice.

FAQ

Questions, answered

Who is it best for?+
Anyone who wants a gentle, hygienic daily balm for base and light-to-medium makeup.
Does it remove heavy or waterproof makeup?+
It handles base and light-to-medium makeup; for waterproof or full point makeup, double-cleanse or use a dedicated remover.
Why a squeeze tube?+
The squeeze format means no spatula and no water getting into a jar, so the balm stays more hygienic than a pot.
Is it fragrance-free?+
Yes. It is fragrance-free and PEG-free with a large plant-extract complex; all 33 ingredients screen low-risk.
Does the texture change, and can it sting?+
It softens in summer and firms in winter, and it can sting if it gets into the eyes, so keep it away from the eye area.
SHINGMULNARA Young Green Tea Tube Cleansing Balm 100ml $14.99

Reviews

Reviews & ratings

Honest, verified reviews from people who actually bought this — collected independently through Loox.

No reviews yet

Be the first to share how it worked for you. We only publish verified reviews — collected through Loox after a real purchase — so every rating here is honest.

Write a review
Verified reviews only

You may also like

Screened picks that pair well

Related to what you're viewing — each one graded ingredient by ingredient before it earned a place.

Browse all
8grow Scalp-Care Pro-Vitamin B5 Hair Tonic 100mlSale9.3Screened

Hair Mist

8grow Scalp-Care Pro-Vitamin B5 Hair Tonic 100ml

$12.90$24

Dhaliora · Screened 9.3
Amazon #1 · Kitsch Warm Sugar Hair Perfume 8.4
Olive Young #1 · UNOVE Water Essence Mist 8.7

Why we picked itA leave-on anti-hairloss scalp tonic with pro-vitamin B5, salicylic acid, menthol and copper peptides, cooling, non-sticky, and the #1-ranked hair mist on Hwahae, Korea's beauty-review platform, with 2,500+ Hwahae reviews.
AGAINME BB Scalp-Clear Fortifying Shampoo 400mlSale8.9Screened

Shampoo

AGAINME BB Scalp-Clear Fortifying Shampoo 400ml

$29.99$48

Dhaliora · Screened 8.9
Amazon #1 · Olaplex No.4 Bond Maintenance Shampoo 8.8
Olive Young #1 · LABO-H Scalp Strengthening Shampoo (Hair-Loss Relief) 8.8

Why we picked itA sulfate-free, weakly-acidic anti-hairloss functional shampoo with salicylic acid, niacinamide and biotin, positioned by the brand for postpartum and pregnancy-related shedding.
ANEAN Argan Oil Curling Up Hair Lotion 150mlSale9.8Screened

Styling

ANEAN Argan Oil Curling Up Hair Lotion 150ml

$20.80$23.80

Dhaliora · Screened 9.8
Amazon #1 · Olaplex No.6 Bond Smoother 8.8
Olive Young #1 · Gatsby Set & Keep Spray Super Hard 8.3

Why we picked itA minimalist argan-oil curl lotion, free of the silicones, alcohol and fragrance most styling creams contain.
Beauty Recipe Little Mermaid This Is Princess Cleansing Water 500mlSale9.3Screened

Cleansing Water

Beauty Recipe Little Mermaid This Is Princess Cleansing Water 500ml

$19.99$23.99

Dhaliora · Screened 9.3
Amazon #1 · Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water (All-in-1) 8.9
Olive Young #1 · innisfree Green Tea Cleansing Water 8.5

Why we picked itA twelve-ingredient, alcohol- and fragrance-free micellar cleansing water that lifts light makeup while hydrating, gentler than surfactant- or silicone-heavy removers.
Beauty Recipe Snow White Ingrown-Hair After-Waxing Scrub 500gSale9.5Screened

Body Scrub

Beauty Recipe Snow White Ingrown-Hair After-Waxing Scrub 500g

$10.99$29

Dhaliora · Screened 9.5
Amazon #1 · First Aid Beauty KP Bump Eraser Body Scrub 8.8
Olive Young #1 · Aromatica Sugar Body Scrub (Basil & Bergamot) 8.8

Why we picked itA sugar-and-enzyme body scrub that smooths away ingrown hairs after waxing, physical polish plus a rice ferment and brightening niacinamide, with no harsh acids.
bellpo Rice Water Deep Cleansing Wipes 20ea9.8Screened

Cleansing Tissue & Pad

bellpo Rice Water Deep Cleansing Wipes 20ea

$4.53

Dhaliora · Screened 9.8
Amazon #1 · Neutrogena Makeup Remover Cleansing Towelettes 7.9
Olive Young #1 · Ariul The Perfect Cleansing Tissue Plus 8.9

Why we picked itA fragrance- and alcohol-free rice-bran-water cleansing wipe loaded with soothing cica, peptides and hyaluronic acid, gentler than fragranced or alcohol-based makeup wipes.
Birthtii Glow Hand & Body Wash [Cake from Susie] 400mlSale9.1Screened

Hand Wash

Birthtii Glow Hand & Body Wash [Cake from Susie] 400ml

$24$32

Dhaliora · Screened 9.1
Amazon #1 · Puracy Natural Gel Hand Soap (Lavender & Vanilla) 9.0
Olive Young #1 · Method Gel Hand Wash French Lavender 8.9

Why we picked itA barrier-supporting hand and body wash that adds ceramides and niacinamide where most washes offer only surfactants.
Birthtii Layered Hand & Body Lotion [Cake from Susie] 400mlSale9.3Screened

Hand Cream & Balm

Birthtii Layered Hand & Body Lotion [Cake from Susie] 400ml

$24.75$33

Dhaliora · Screened 9.3
Amazon #1 · eos Shea Better Body Lotion 9.0
Olive Young #1 · Illiyoon Ceramide Ato Concentrate Lotion 9.1

Why we picked itA ceramide-and-cholesterol barrier lotion with more skin-identical lipids and fewer heavy occlusives than typical drugstore hand creams.