The Journal

The science behind the screening.

We read ingredient lists for a living. Here's what we've learned — evidence first, marketing last.

Industry

Korea Banned Plastic Microbeads in 2017. What Replaced Them in Our Catalogue Is Sugar, Sea Salt and Powdered Mung Bean.

We went through all 1,920 ingredient rows looking for plastic scrub particles and found none, which is what a decade of overlapping bans in Korea, the US, the UK and the EU was supposed to produce. The five physical exfoliants we do sell are sugar, sea salt, mung bean powder, mint leaf powder and amber, and nothing in any of those rules says a natural particle has to be gentle.

Sep 7, 2026·6 min read
By the Numbers

One of Our Ampoules Lists Collagen Seven Times Under Seven Different Names

Collagen, soluble collagen, atelocollagen, desamidocollagen, procollagen, collagen amino acids and hydrolyzed collagen all appear on one ingredient list in our catalogue, spread across positions 8 to 57. Every one of those names is a legitimate INCI entry, which is exactly what makes the effect work.

Sep 7, 2026·5 min read
Ingredient Deep-Dive

There's Vitamin K3 in a Toner We Scored 9.5. We Flagged It Anyway.

Menadione sits twentieth of thirty ingredients in a toner we score 9.5, and it is the only high-risk grade on a face product in our catalog. Here is the chemistry, the regulatory gap it falls into, and why the number did not move.

Aug 14, 2026·9 min read
Routine

Sunscreen Reapplication in the Real World: Stick vs Mist vs Cushion

Every SPF number on every bottle is measured at 2 mg of product per square centimetre; in the field people apply about 0.39. We weighed a stick, a mist and a cushion against that standard, and found that nobody has ever published a measurement for two of the three.

Aug 10, 2026·9 min read
Label Decoder

The Price-Per-Milliliter Trap: Why the 400ml Toner Isn't the Better Deal

Price per millilitre quietly assumes the last millilitre is worth the same as the first, and nothing in the regulations guarantees that. We ran our own shelf through the arithmetic, including the 400ml toner we sell at the worst per-millilitre rate in its category.

Aug 10, 2026·9 min read
GDS

Eight Ingredients in Our Own Catalog Got Our Worst Grade. Here They All Are.

Eight ingredient entries in our 1,696-row screen carry our worst grade, and every one of them sits in a product we currently sell. Here are all six products by name, what each flagged ingredient is actually doing there, and the three defects we found in our own scoring while writing it.

Aug 10, 2026·10 min read
Routine

Double Cleansing: Who Actually Needs It, and Who's Just Washing Twice for Nothing

Plain water leaves 59.3% of a waterproof sunscreen on your face, and a foaming cleanser still leaves 36.8%, so the oil step is doing real work for anyone who wears one. But the barrier-stripping mechanism everybody cites for the cost of a second cleanse did not survive the papers we read.

Aug 10, 2026·10 min read